取引信用保険
When the Credit Limit Falls Short — Why Limits Are Reduced or Declined, and Five Things Policyholders Can Do
When a trade credit insurer will not grant the limit you want on a key buyer, or reduces it mid-term, what is the insurer looking at, and what can the policyholder do, step by step? Based on public material from credit insurers and financial institutions.
The question companies using trade credit insurance raise most often is not the premium but the credit limit: the limit requested on a key buyer was not granted, the limit shrinks at every renewal, or a reduction notice arrived mid-term without warning. The limit is the ceiling on what the policy will pay, so if it falls short, the receivables that matter most are not protected even though you are insured.
This article sets out, in order, why limits are not granted as requested and what policyholders can do.
The limit is the ceiling on the claim
According to credit insurers, the claim is calculated as the lower of the loss on the insured receivable and the credit limit, multiplied by a set insured percentage. For example, if you are owed JPY 30 million by a buyer, the limit is JPY 10 million and the insured percentage is 90%, the claim paid if that buyer fails is JPY 9 million. The remaining JPY 21 million is your loss even though you are insured.
The real value of the policy therefore depends on whether your largest buyers have limits that match what they owe you. Before comparing premium rates, start by listing each buyer's outstanding balance next to its limit.
What the insurer is looking at
Credit insurers analyze the credit risk of each buyer to set a limit, and keep monitoring the buyer after the limit is set. The main information they consider is:
- Financials: latest accounts, equity, level of borrowing, cash flow
- Payment behavior: whether there are overdue payments, and how often. Because credit insurers receive overdue notifications from many policyholders, they can see changes in a company's payment behavior early.
- Sector and country trends: sectors where insolvencies are rising, countries with unstable political or economic conditions
- Accumulation: the total limits the insurer has granted on the same buyer across all its policyholders
Accumulation is hard for the policyholder to see. To avoid paying claims on many policies at once when one buyer fails, insurers manage the total they will write per buyer. The larger and more widely traded a buyer is, the more policyholders apply for limits on it, so a request can fall short even when the buyer's credit is sound.
Find out why the limit was declined or reduced
The starting point is to find out the reason. Reasons fall broadly into three groups, and each calls for a different response.
| Reason | What it means | Effective response |
|---|---|---|
| Lack of information | The insurer does not have enough to judge, e.g. accounts are unavailable or out of date | Provide additional information |
| Credit concerns | Weakening financials, overdue payments, etc. | Review trading terms. Other insurers often reach a similar view |
| Accumulation | The insurer has reached the total it can write on that buyer | Approach other insurers; top-up cover |
How much insurers disclose varies, but simply finding out whether it is an information problem, a credit problem or a capacity problem changes what you do next.
Five things policyholders can do
1. Provide more information and ask for a review
If you can obtain the buyer's latest accounts or monthly management accounts, submit them. Information that only you have as the seller, such as how long you have traded with the buyer and its payment record, or its order book and main customers, can also support the review. This is particularly effective for unlisted buyers, where the insurer's information is limited.
2. Review trading terms
Shortening payment terms reduces the outstanding balance for the same sales, and so reduces the limit you need. For a buyer with monthly sales of JPY 10 million, the outstanding balance can reach about JPY 30 million on terms of payment at the end of the second month after month-end, but drops to about JPY 20 million if terms change to payment at the end of the following month. Taking advance payments, settling part in cash, or obtaining security or guarantees also reduce the limit needed. The idea is to solve an insurance problem from the trading-terms side.
3. Approach other insurers
Different insurers assess the same buyer differently and have different accumulations. A limit refused by one insurer may be granted by another. However, under a whole turnover policy you would be moving the whole policy, so compare limits on your other buyers, premium and insured percentage as well. It makes no sense to worsen the overall terms for the sake of one buyer's limit.
4. Consider top-up cover
Top-up cover adds protection from another insurer on top of the limit granted under the existing policy. It lets you keep the existing policy and fill the gap only for the buyers that fall short. Because top-up cover takes on risk the primary policy declined, its premium is usually higher than the primary policy's.
5. Combine with other tools such as guarantee factoring
Guarantee factoring offered by bank-affiliated factoring companies lets you choose which buyers to guarantee and pays 100% within the guarantee limit. Some companies use it only for amounts above their internal credit limit. It can fill the gap for specific buyers where the insurance falls short. However, guarantee limits are also based on the buyer's credit, and may differ from the amount requested. If the insurer declined because of credit concerns, the guarantee may come out the same. The differences between the two are set out in trade credit insurance vs. guarantee factoring.
When a reduction notice arrives mid-term
Reductions and cancellations usually apply to shipments made after the notice. When you receive one, first check:
- When the reduction takes effect, and how receivables shipped before then are treated
- Whether the current balance exceeds the reduced limit
- Whether there are orders accepted but not yet shipped
- The reason for the reduction (to the extent disclosed)
Then decide whether to keep shipping, change terms or request a review. A reduction notice may mean the insurer has seen some change in the buyer's credit standing. Treat it not just as an insurance formality but as credit management information. If the notice does not reach the sales team and shipments continue, uninsured exposure above the limit builds up. Decide in advance the internal route from receiving a notice to stopping shipments.
When limits shrink at every renewal
If limits are being cut across the policy rather than on particular buyers, individual responses will not solve it. Review the following:
- Loss history: insurers become cautious on policies with many past claims. Showing that you detect overdue payments early and collect effectively helps in negotiating terms.
- Buyer portfolio: concentration in a particular sector or a few buyers leads insurers to rate the overall risk higher.
- Policy type: if limits are hard to obtain under a policy covering selected buyers, switching to a whole turnover policy can make it easier for the insurer to assess the risk as a whole.
- Market conditions: when insolvencies are rising, insurers as a whole become more cautious. Credit insurers' published insolvency forecasts indicate the direction (see our insight on the insolvency outlook).
If the limit still cannot be obtained
Even after trying everything, the limit you want may not be granted. Then whether to bear the uninsured risk yourself becomes a management decision. That decision requires knowing, buyer by buyer, which part is insured and which is not. The fact that a limit cannot be obtained may itself be a reason to review how much you trade with that buyer.
How Credit Hills can help
Credit Hills' team has underwriting experience at credit insurers. We find out why a limit was declined or reduced, organize the information the insurer needs and request a review, and we approach other insurers and arrange top-up cover. We cannot guarantee the limit you want, but we will set out the concrete options available.
See our trade credit insurance services → What is trade credit insurance (insight) →